Pd Prosperity Discussion

Isn’t this project situated on land that belongs to the First Nations?

New Prosperity Team says:

No. The New Prosperity site is situated on Crown land, which was confirmed by the Supreme Court of British Columbia, in 2007. The ruling said that the Tsilhqot’in people have the right to hunt and trap birds and animals in the much larger Claim Area in which New Prosperity is located. The New Prosperity Project recognizes and supports these rights.

May 13, 2011 at 12:59 am

9 comments so far. Sort by:

  1. Natalie Guttormsson says:

    Is this not a spin of words depending on how you look at it? Crown land meaning no treaty was signed therefore, as Taseko puts it, no agreement has been made to assign the land as a ‘reserve’ for First Nations. But if you look at it from the other side, no treaty means the Xeni Gwet’in never ceded their land to the government, it was simply assumed to be property of Canada by colonizers. And if the Tsilhqot’in people have protected rights to hunt and trap on the land where the massive open pit mine is to be located, how is the project not recognized as a massive threat to those rights? This is the same threat that the first ‘Prosperity’ plan posed and part of why it was rejected by the federal government.

     Thumb down 44

  2. steve laciak says:

    Is a 200 acre lake really worth $300 million. Canadians must be worth trillions based on this arithmetic. Won't the local First Nations just accept $100 million ($50,000 a person in this area) and save Taseko $200 million.

     Thumb down 20

  3. Regan Welder says:

    When you speak that this is crown land you are talking as the ruler and not from the prisoners point of view. The First nations people have been prisoners of war now for more then 300 years and longer. There land right claims have been taken from them as our society evolves each and every year. How can you say what progression is? When is it all right to take land that isn't yours, destroy is and leave toxic lakes and holes and then call it progress?

     Thumb down 54

  4. Meryl lou says:

    Why are the aboriginals against this plan? Is the mining company treading on native territory that has been untouched and protected for centuries?

     Thumb down 7

  5. Meryl lou says:

    Will this affect the aboriginal way of living?

     Thumb down 0

Leave a Reply

Submit a comment

By posting on this site you agree to the terms and conditions.

I would like to receive notifications on the activity of this post.